Indonesian Environmental News

Thursday, October 07, 2004

Stop buying APP’s products!

Sumatera, one of biggest islands in Indonesia, with area of 476,000 square kilometer has over 10,000 species of higher plants. Most of them are found in lowland forest. It has the most mammals (201 species). Nine species of mammals are endemic to mainland Sumatera and 14 species are endemic on the Mentawai islands. To add more, Sumatera has 580 species of birds.

Unfortunately, all the plants and animals are in the brink of extinction because of forest destruction. Illegal logging, forest fires, and forest conversion into wood plantation are causes of deforestation. According to Forest Watch Indonesia (a network of non-governmental organization) deforestation rate is more than two million hectares per year.

A World Bank study estimates that unless logging practices radically change, there will be no more lowland rainforest left in Sumatra by 2005.

A study done by CIFOR (Center for International Forestry Research) in Indonesia and WWF’s Macroeconomics Program Officer in December 2000 showed that the Indonesian pulp and paper industry is causing serious damage to Indonesian forests and is likely to be responsible for illegal logging practices.

The pulp and paper industry has been responsible for the destruction of almost one million hectares of Indonesian rainforest. The industry will depend upon clearing rainforests to supply their pulp requirements for at least the next seven years and possibly much longer, concluded the study.

And Asia Pulp and Paper Inc. Ltd., a Singapore registered company and owned by Sinar Mas Group (SMG) and listed on New York Stock Exchange, is one of several companies responsible for destroying a large area of Indonesia’s forests.

APP is one of the world’s biggest pulp and paper companies. Its pulp capacity is 2.3 million tons and its paper/packaging capacity is 5.6 million tons. It has 16 manufacturing facilities in Indonesia and China. It has almost one million hectare of forest concessions in Indonesia. Most of the fibers material is coming from natural forests that clear cut. It will clear cut around 180,000 hectare of biodiversity rich natural forest until 2007 to supply its hungry mills.

It markets its products in more than 65 countries through out the world, including Japan. APP sells around 20,000 tons of photocopy paper (branded as Paperline) per month to Japan. It is about a quarter of its total sales.

APP and SMG’s other subsidiary pulp and paper mills are also responsible for three cases of human rights abuse and for destroying forests in Riau, Sumatera, according to Human Rights Watch a US based human rights organization.

To push APP/SMG to be more environmental friendly, in August 2003, APP/SMG (and its fiber suppliers PT Arara Abadi, PT Mapala Rabda, PT Satria Perkasa Agung, PT Wira Karya Sakti) and World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) Indonesia signed a Letter of Intent to work together to protect the natural heritage of Riau and Jambi Provinces, in Sumatera. APP/SMG agreed to prepare an action plan for the next 12 years on the sustainability wood supplies and the conservation of forest of high social and environmental significance.

In details, APP/SMG agreed that conservation value assessments should take place before forests are converted to Acacia plantations so that identified values can be conserved. APP/SMG also agreed to resolve land disputes with communities, fully comply with national laws, and agreed that protected areas within and adjacent to SMG’s plantations should be designed to maximize conservation benefits by including wildlife corridors and greater border protection.

The deadline to submit the plan was on 19 February 2004.

On January 2004, APP/SMG submitted its plan to be discussed with WWF Indonesia. After several meetings, including a meeting in Japan on February 2004, the negotiation broke down without an agreement over a sustainability plan. WWF Indonesia could not accept.

The plan was not adequately addressed issues on protection of forests with high conservation values, use of third party mediators in social conflicts, and long-term sustainability.

“We could not accept the plan,” said Nazir Foead, a lead negotiator from WWF Indonesia, “Since APP refused to use high conservation value forest assessment, which is internationally recognized and refused to impose temporary moratorium on natural forests of its concession while the assessment is being conducted.”

Executive Director of Friends of the Earth Indonesia Walhi (Indonesian Environmental Forum) Riau Chapter, Rully Syumanda said to the press that he was not surprised that APP would not comply. “I have evidence that APP involved in illegal logging practices.”

He said that APP has been involved in illegal logging practices in several conservation areas, such as Giam Siak Kecil, Bukit Batu, Minas, Rimbang Baling. “We investigated that around 80 percent of illegal logs from Minas were sent to PT Arara Abadi, a fiber supplier company to APP.”

Report issued by Human Rights Watch, a New York based human rights organization, in January 2003, brought out three human rights abuse cases in 2001 which involve APP. Residents of three villages refused to give up their land to APP’s wood supplier PT Arara Abadi. Some villages injured attacked by company militia.

“APP is committed to being a fully sustainable Indonesian pulp and paper company in 2007,” said Michael Black, APP’s Deputy CEO in a statement to media on 20 February 2004. The statement said that the plan has included creating a contiguous 165,000 hectare conservation park in Riau Province, Sumatera.

Quoted by Down Jones (19 March 2004), APP spokesperson said that WWF Indonesia’s demand to stop cutting forest is “impossible.” APP needs to harvest wood in order to expand its plantations to become self-sustaining. “We still want to sit down with them (WWF Indonesia), but only if they’re logical.”

Foead said, “Yes, the plan showed that APP has integrated some WWF Indonesia’s demands but it disappointingly has not addressed some of the basic concerns.” For example, APP’s plan to have sustainable wood supply from plantation in 2007 will be achieved at the expense of 180,000 hectares of natural forest and the company has refused to put these forests under temporary moratorium while credible conservation assessments are carried out.

WWF Indonesia is also concern that the companies only assessed the human impact on the degradation of forests and failed to consider the crucial role they play in watershed protection, climate regulation and as habitat for key endangered species.

Foead argued that the conservation value of most Indonesia’s forests would be underestimated if the only criteria used was human-induced degradation. “The study should use high conservation value forest assessment, a holistic approach assessment,” explained Foead.

Initially developed by the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC), the high conservation value forest (HCVF) concept was designed as a tool to help forest certification. It is now also being promoted as a more general conservation planning tool. The identification of HCVFs requires a multi-stakeholder, consensus-based approach, with results having buy-in, acceptance and credibility. The process therefore involves a wide range of expertise — from biology to social science, from forest management to GIS — and includes consultation with local communities.

He was also concerned that APP/SMG failed to give commitments on the appointment of an independent mediator in land dispute with local communities.

Based on APP’s past performance, WWF Indonesia is worried that many more natural forests may be cleared because the company will be unable to meet what WWF Indonesia considers are overly ambitious plantation productivity and planting target.

“Now we are asking consumers to put pressure on APP/SMG to be more environmental friendly,” said Foead.

In 2001, United Kingdom paper buyers canceled contracts after Friends of the Earth launched a media campaign against APP. In Germany, department store operator KarstadtQuelle AG also stopped buying APP products after pressure from local NGOs.

Dow Jones Business News on 19 February 2004 reported that one important U.S. customer, Delray Beach, Florida-based Office Depot Inc., announced it already has cut off its orders with APP until it sees "tangible evidence of a sustainable source." APP's Japanese customers, led by Ricoh Co. (RICOY or 7752), the country's top manufacturer of copy machines, have also threatened in the past to terminate contracts.

Consumers power around the world will help conserve Indonesia natural rich forests. (Harry Surjadi)

Do not buy ramin products from Malaysia

Ramin (Gonystylus spp.) is a wonderful kind of tropical hard-wood with high value because its appearance, fine grain and easy working properties. Its color is blond and creamy yellow light. Ramin use to be made into pictures and futon frames, blinds, moldings, pool or snooker cues, baby cribs or cots, and mop handles.

Most of the ramin products are made in China, Hong Kong and Taiwan, according to Environmental Investigation Agency who did market survey. Then the products export largely to Japan, EU, and USA. But the raw materials come from Malaysia and Indonesia because ramin is native to these two countries.

The tree grows in the lowland freshwater swamps and peat swamp forest in Borneo, Sumatera, Peninsular Malaysia. In Borneo ramin trees exist in protected and conservation areas such as Tanjung Putting National Park a home of the Asian great ape, orangutan. And ramin in Malaysia is becoming increasingly scarce.

Fifteen species of ramin have been classified by World Conservation Monitoring Center as vulnerable and put in IUCN Red List of Threatened Species.

As a swamp species, ramin is prone to over exploitation and cannot cultivated on plantations. Ramin populations have been heavily depleted as the most important source of ramin timber. These species are also threatened in parts of its range by habitat loss.

The illegal loggers will receive about US$2.20 per cubic meter and by the time the wood product reaches consumers in Japan the cost is US$1,000 per cubic meter.

“Seeking international help, Indonesia listed the species on Appendix III of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species or CITES,” told Allan Thornton from Environmental Investigation Agency (EIA), an NGO based in London and Washington DC, in a press conference held in accordance with 7th Conference of Parties of United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, on February 12, 2004.

The Appendix III listing, which came into affect in August 2001, means that consuming countries must only allow the import of ramin products with official CITES documents from exporting government. 155 countries including Malaysia are signatories of CITES.

While Indonesian ramin requires a CITES Export permit, ramin from Malaysia requires a CITES Certificate of Origin guaranteeing that it did not originate elsewhere. All CITES Parties are required to issue CITES certificates for any re-export or ramin or ramin products and must only issue these if they are satisfied that the wood was imported legally with CITES documents.

But Malaysia as a range country put reservation to the Convention for ramin parts and derivatives other than logs and sawn timber. In August 2001 Government of Malaysia entered an official reservation against the listing of ramin parts and products. According to EIA, Malaysia opposed the listing from the start.

In December 2001 Indonesian government banned all cutting and export of ramin wood species. But still ramin (and other wood) from Indonesia has been smuggled into Malaysia although Indonesian Government and Malaysian last year have signed an agreement on combating illegal logging between the two countries.

For about three years EIA and its partner an Indonesian NGO Telapak, have been carrying out investigations of illegal ramin trade from Indonesia to Malaysia. “A single port in Malaysia handles up to 70,000 cubic meters of endangered ramin timber each year,” said Alexander von Bismarck, one of the EIA investigators, in the same press conference.

EIA and Telapak released a new report in Jakarta and in Kualalumpur recently as 2,000 delegates from up 186 nations attend the UN Biodiversity Convention. The report titled “Profiting from Plunder: How Malaysia Smuggles Endangered Wood,” uncovered how Malaysia laundered illegal logs from Indonesia, especially ramin log, and exported to other countries.

EIA and Telapak’s investigators have documented countless trucks and ships carrying illegal Indonesian wood entering Malaysia in dozen locations across the country. The logs come from Jambi Province and Riau Province in Sumatera to several ports in Peninsular Malaysia, which are Batu Pahat, Muar, Melaka, Port Klang, and Johor Port. And some logs across the border of Indonesia and Sarawak.

According to EIA/Telapak investigation, ramin logs also have been smuggled into Singapore. EIA/Telapak issued a separate report, titled “Singapore’s Illegal Timber Trade.”

But, “The Malaysian Government and timber industry are in a state of denial with their smuggling of illegal timber,” said Allan Thornton.

In a press conference after the opening ceremony of ministerial section in 7th Conference of Parties, Deputy Prime Minister of Malaysia, Mohamad Najib, said to the reporters, “There is no such thing,” as a comment to the report issued by EIA/Telapak.

Minister of Primary Industry of Malaysia, Dr Lim Keng Yaik, for several times, was quoted by press that he denied the accusation from EIA/Telapak.

Malaysian Timber Council in harmony with Malaysian Government rejected the generalization and grossly overstated claims made by EIA/Telapak in their report. “Malaysia does not condone any illegal trade in timber and has implemented various measures to combat the entry of illegal logs and timber into Malaysia. Enforcement measures have been stepped up and will continue to be strengthened,” the statement of MTC in a press release distributed in EIA’s press conference.

EIA/Telapak unveiled that some traders and officials in Malaysia still profit from huge quantities of smuggled Indonesian ramin and fraudulently sell them onto international market as “origin Malaysia.”

“Malaysia Government and timber companies are undercutting international efforts to protect biodiversity, endangered species and protected areas by turning a blind eye to large scale smuggling of illegal cut Indonesia ramin and other timber species through its territory and onto world markets in China, Taiwan, US, Japan, and European Union countries,” said Allan Thornton.

To push Malaysia to act, a coalition of leading US environmental groups (including Natureal Resources Defence Council, the Sierra Club, Greenpeace, Defenders of Wildlife, Rainforest Action Network, Earth Justice, and Orangutan Foundation International) representing millions of members and supporters in US and around the world have joined EIA sending a petition to US Secretary of State Colin Powell to raise the issue with Malaysia and impose trade sanctions under the US Pelly Amendment unless Malaysia takes meaningful action to resolve the problem, told von Bismach.

In their report EIA/Telapak named several Malaysian companies that involved in smuggling and illegal trading of ramin wood. And, according to Director of Telapak Hapsoro who met Dr Lim in Kualalumpur several days ago, Dr Lim promised to arrest the person mentioned in the report.

Indonesian Environmental Minister Nabiel Makarim, who attended the Conference, in a formal press conference, said “Lately there is a tendency of pointing fingers at each other. Let’s stop that. Let’s meet and be serious and quick because this is a serious problem.”

Meanwhile in Jakarta, Indonesian Minister of Foresty M Prakosa, on 13 February 2004, as quoted in The Jakarta Post, called for a worldwide boycott of Malaysian wood products.

He said in his trip to Kalimantan near the borders of Malaysian Serawak, he saw heavy-duty equipment and he suspected that the equipment belonged to Malaysian citizens that have committed illegal logging.

Last year Foreign Ministry office has asked the European Union to stop importing wood products from Malaysia based on strong indications that its wood products were made from illegal logs from Indonesia.

“The problem of illegal logging and illegal trade of logs, as other international crimes, must be curbed at both sides. The supply side, it’s in Indonesia, and the demand side must be attended at the same time equally,” said Minister Makarim. “We are doing out best to stop illegal logging. At the moment, we have 48 cases in my office alone to go to court.”

He said that Indonesian Government’s efforts become much more difficult because of the problem at the demand side. “Some countries are still indiscriminate between legal and illegal logs and others are function as transit. Like international traffic of drugs, as long as the demand is big, it is difficult to curb in the supply side”

Then he asked Malaysia to be an important factor in curbing the practice at the demand side. One of the reasons he mentioned that because illegal logging make forest-fire potential increase significantly. “The haze will come from peat-areas where ramin can only grow. Decimating ramin will result in increasing of potential for larger scale haze problem that Malaysia also will suffer.”

To help Indonesia curbing illegal logging practices, consumers have to boycott wood products made of Indonesia or Malaysian illegal logs, especially ramin wood. Do not buy wood products made of ramin! (Harry Surjadi)